Retraction
Procedure for the Retraction of Published Materials
The scientific journal Agape adheres to the principles of accountability for the reliability of published research, academic integrity, and transparency in editorial decision-making. In cases where significant errors, breaches of publication ethics, or other circumstances that cast doubt on the reliability of research findings are identified, the Editorial Board applies procedures for correcting or retracting publications in accordance with the recommendations of the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE).
1. General Provisions
1.1. This procedure establishes the grounds, principles, and process for the retraction of scholarly materials published in the journal Agape.
1.2. Retraction is the formal withdrawal of a scholarly publication whose findings or conclusions have been deemed unreliable, or whose publication process involved significant breaches of academic integrity or publishing ethics.
1.3. The primary purpose of retraction is to correct the scholarly record, prevent the further dissemination of unreliable findings, and ensure transparency in academic communication. Retraction is not regarded as a means of punishing authors but rather as a mechanism for maintaining the reliability of scholarly information.
1.4. The retraction procedure may be initiated by the authors of a publication, the journal's Editorial Board, reviewers, readers, representatives of academic institutions, or other individuals who possess substantiated information concerning possible significant breaches.
1.5. The decision to retract a publication is made on the basis of an objective analysis of the established circumstances, in compliance with the principles of impartiality, confidentiality, and the right of interested parties to provide explanations.
2. Grounds for Retraction
The grounds for considering the retraction of a published article may include:
- Academic plagiarism: established cases of the unauthorised use of others' texts, ideas, concepts, translations, or research findings without proper attribution.
- Unreliable research findings: the identification of significant errors in methodology, source analysis, data processing, or argumentation that render the principal conclusions of the study unreliable.
- Fabrication and falsification: established cases of inventing, deliberately distorting, or manipulating research data, documents, sources, or findings.
- Duplicate publication: the republication of substantially identical research findings without proper reference to the previous publication, adequate justification, or the required permission.
- Copyright infringement: the unauthorised use of third-party materials or other significant violations of intellectual property rights.
- Misconduct in the editorial process: the identification of manipulation of the peer-review procedure, fraudulent peer review, false attribution of authorship, or other actions that substantially undermine the integrity of the publication process.
- Undisclosed significant conflict of interest: circumstances that may have substantially affected the reliability of the reported findings, their interpretation, or the independence of expert evaluation.
- Serious breaches of research ethics: failure to respect the rights of research participants, comply with confidentiality requirements, obtain informed consent, or observe other mandatory ethical standards, where the nature of the breach warrants retraction of the publication.
In view of the scholarly profile of Agape, particular attention is paid to cases involving the systematic distortion of the content of primary sources, falsification of quotations, improper attribution of ideas to particular authors or traditions, and the use of non-existent sources to substantiate research conclusions.
At the same time, differences in philosophical, theological, or religious studies interpretations, criticism of an author's position, or its reinterpretation in subsequent research do not, in themselves, constitute grounds for retraction.
3. Forms of Response to Deficiencies in Published Materials
Depending on the nature and significance of the identified problems, the Editorial Board of Agape may apply the following forms of response:
Correction. Applied in cases where errors or inaccuracies are identified in a published article that require formal correction but do not call into question the reliability of the study's principal findings and conclusions. Information about substantive corrections is published in a separate editorial notice.
Expression of Concern. May be issued when substantiated doubts arise regarding the reliability of a study or the integrity of the publication process, if an investigation is ongoing or the available evidence is insufficient to reach a final decision.
Retraction. Applied in cases where established significant deficiencies or violations render the research findings unreliable or indicate a substantial breach of the integrity of the publication process.
The choice of the appropriate measure is based on the nature of the established circumstances, their impact on the reliability of the research, and COPE recommendations.
4. Initiation of the Retraction Procedure
4.1. A request concerning the possible retraction of a publication must be submitted in writing to the journal's official email address: agape@chnu.edu.ua
4.2. The request must include bibliographic details of the relevant publication, the grounds justifying its possible retraction, and any available evidence or references to information sources.
4.3. The Editorial Board may also consider anonymous reports, provided they contain sufficiently specific and verifiable information concerning possible violations.
4.4. The Editor-in-Chief conducts a preliminary review of the request, normally within 7 working days of its receipt.
4.5. Following the preliminary review, a decision is made on whether to initiate an appropriate investigation, whether additional information is required, or whether there are insufficient grounds for further consideration of the request.
5. Investigation Procedure and Consideration of Retraction
5.1. Where substantiated grounds for an investigation exist, the Editor-in-Chief organises consideration of the matter with the involvement of members of the Editorial Board and, where necessary, independent experts.
5.2. In complex or disputed cases, an expert committee consisting of at least three specialists with expertise in the relevant field of research and independent of the parties involved in the proceedings may be established.
5.3. Individuals who have a conflict of interest relating to the subject of the investigation or its participants may not take part in the decision-making process concerning retraction.
5.4. During the investigation, the published article, relevant primary sources, editorial review materials, reviewers' reports, submitted evidence, and any other information necessary to establish the circumstances objectively are examined.
5.5. The authors of the publication are given the opportunity to familiarise themselves with the substance of the allegations, provide written explanations, and submit additional documents or other materials relevant to the consideration of the matter.
5.6. If the matter concerns possible breaches of research integrity, the Editorial Board may contact the relevant academic institution and request that the circumstances be investigated within its remit.
5.7. The Editorial Board endeavours to complete its internal review within 30 calendar days of the decision to initiate the investigation. In cases requiring additional expert assessment, inter-institutional cooperation, or complex fact-finding, this period may be extended, with the interested parties duly informed.
5.8. If the investigation requires an extended period of time and the doubts concerning the reliability of the publication are sufficiently serious, the Editorial Board may issue an Expression of Concern before reaching a final decision.
6. Decision-Making on Retraction
6.1. Following the investigation, the Editorial Board may adopt one of the following decisions:
- to reject the request for retraction due to insufficient grounds;
- to publish a correction or clarification to the article;
- to issue an Expression of Concern regarding the reliability of the publication pending the completion of further investigation;
- to decide to retract the article.
6.2. Recommendations from the experts or committee involved are taken into account when making the decision; however, final responsibility for retraction rests with the journal's Editor-in-Chief or, where the Editor-in-Chief has a conflict of interest, another duly authorised editor.
6.3. The decision must be based on established facts, duly reasoned, and consistent with the principle of proportionality in the measures applied.
6.4. A publication may be retracted regardless of whether all its authors consent, provided that the established circumstances constitute sufficient grounds for retraction in accordance with international standards of publication ethics.
7. Formalisation and Publication of a Retraction
7.1. If a decision to retract a publication is made, the Editorial Board publishes a separate notice entitled "Retraction" on the journal's official website.
7.2. The retraction notice must include:
- the title and full bibliographic details of the retracted article;
- the names of the authors of the relevant publication;
- a clear justification of the reasons for retraction;
- identification of the party that made or initiated the relevant decision;
- the date of publication of the notice;
- an active link to the retracted article and its Digital Object Identifier (DOI), if assigned.
7.3. The retraction notice must be publicly accessible, clearly identifiable, and linked to the original publication.
7.4. As a rule, the retracted article remains accessible in the journal's electronic archive with a prominent "RETRACTED" label. The corresponding marking is displayed on the publication page and in its full-text version.
7.5. Complete removal of the text from public access is permitted only in exceptional cases, including where there are substantiated legal grounds, a need to protect personal data, or a need to prevent other significant harm. Where possible, information about the removal and the reasons for it is retained in the public scholarly record.
7.6. The Editorial Board ensures that the relevant changes are made to the publication's metadata and, where technically possible, that information about the retraction is transmitted to the relevant registration, indexing, and archiving systems.
7.7. The retraction notice is published without undue delay following the final decision, regardless of the publication date of the journal's next issue.
8. Authors' Rights and Appeals Procedure
8.1. Authors have the right to receive written notification of the retraction decision, including the principal grounds on which it was made.
8.2. Authors may submit a reasoned appeal if they believe that the decision was made in violation of the editorial procedure, on the basis of unreliable information, or without due consideration of significant circumstances.
8.3. Appeals must be submitted to the journal's email address agape@chnu.edu.ua and are considered in accordance with the Agape Editorial Policy on Complaints and Appeals.
8.4. The Editorial Board endeavours to consider an appeal within 15 calendar days of its receipt. If the appeal requires additional independent expert assessment, this period may be extended, with the appellant duly notified.
8.5. Individuals who have a conflict of interest relating to the subject of the appeal shall not participate in the decision-making process following its consideration.
8.6. The submission of an appeal does not automatically suspend the retraction decision. If new circumstances are established that alter the assessment of the publication's reliability, the Editorial Board ensures that the results of the reconsideration are duly documented and published.
9. Final Provisions
The retraction procedure is an integral part of the overall system for ensuring publication ethics and academic integrity at the journal Agape.
The Editorial Board regards the retraction of scholarly publications as an exceptional but necessary mechanism of responsible scholarly publishing, aimed at maintaining the reliability of published research, transparency in academic communication, and trust in research findings.
The application of retraction must not restrict academic freedom, the right to reasoned scholarly debate, or the critical reassessment of established interpretations. The decisive criterion is not the conformity of a study with a particular worldview or theoretical position, but its academic integrity, reliability, and compliance with established academic standards.