Conflict of Interest Policy
The scholarly journal Agape adheres to the principles of research independence, impartial expert evaluation, and transparency in editorial decision-making. The identification and proper management of potential conflicts of interest are essential to ensuring academic integrity and maintaining trust in published research findings.
A conflict of interest arises when financial, professional, institutional, personal, or other circumstances may influence, or reasonably appear to influence, the independence of research, the interpretation of its findings, the objectivity of peer review, or editorial decision-making.
The journal recognises that the existence of certain interests or professional relationships does not necessarily constitute a breach of academic integrity. The key requirements are their timely disclosure, transparency, and the proper management of any potential influence on the publication process.
Disclosure of Conflicts of Interest by Authors
Upon submission of a manuscript, all authors are required to disclose to the Editorial Board any actual or potential conflicts of interest that may be related to the research conducted or its findings.
Such circumstances include, but are not limited to:
- Financial interests: grant funding, honoraria, consultancy fees, financial support from organisations, or other material benefits that may be related to the subject of the research.
- Institutional and professional affiliations: collaboration with organisations, institutions, religious communities, or other entities that have a direct interest in the research findings.
- Personal relationships: family, friendship, professional, or other close relationships that could influence the independence of research conclusions or the manuscript evaluation process.
- Other circumstances: obligations, competing interests, or forms of involvement in the subject of the research that may call into question the objectivity of its presentation.
Given the specific nature of philosophical, theological, and religious studies research, Agape distinguishes between a researcher's worldview position and a conflict of interest. An author's affiliation with a particular philosophical school, theological tradition, or religious community does not, in itself, constitute a conflict of interest. However, institutional obligations, financial dependence, or a direct interest on the part of relevant organisations in the research findings must be disclosed if they may affect the independence of scholarly conclusions.
Information about potential conflicts of interest must be provided upon manuscript submission in the "Comments for the Editor" field and included in the relevant disclosure statement within the article. Authors must also disclose the sources of research funding and the role of any organisations providing such support.
In the absence of a conflict of interest, authors must include the following statement: "The author(s) declare(s) that there is no conflict of interest."
Good-faith disclosure of a potential conflict of interest does not, in itself, constitute grounds for rejecting a manuscript. The Editorial Board assesses the nature of the circumstances disclosed and determines the measures necessary to ensure an objective evaluation of the manuscript.
Conflicts of Interest of Reviewers
Reviewers of Agape are required to evaluate manuscripts independently, objectively, and impartially, based solely on their scholarly quality, methodological soundness, and relevance to the journal's scope.
A potential conflict of interest may arise if a reviewer:
-
has a close personal, family, or professional relationship with the author;
-
has recently conducted joint research, co-authored publications, or participated in projects with the author, or has a supervisory relationship with them;
-
is affiliated with the same institution as the author or has other institutional ties that may affect the independence of the evaluation;
-
has a financial, professional, or other direct interest in the acceptance or rejection of the manuscript;
-
is involved in a personal or academic dispute with the author that could compromise the objectivity of the peer review.
In such circumstances, the reviewer must notify the Editorial Board before commencing the evaluation and decline the review if there is a risk of bias.
Differences in scholarly views, methodological approaches, or worldview convictions do not, in themselves, constitute grounds for disqualifying a reviewer, provided that they do not prevent an objective and reasoned evaluation of the manuscript.
Conflicts of Interest of Editors and Editorial Board Members
The Editor-in-Chief, members of the Editorial Board, and other individuals involved in the editorial process are required to disclose any circumstances that may call into question the independence of decisions concerning submitted manuscripts.
Individuals who have a conflict of interest in relation to a particular manuscript must not participate in organising its peer review, evaluating reviewers' reports, or making the final publication decision.
If the Editor-in-Chief or a member of the Editorial Board is an author or co-author of a submitted manuscript, its evaluation must be conducted by other authorised representatives of the Editorial Board, with the involvement of independent reviewers. The author of such a manuscript must not influence the selection of reviewers, the evaluation process, or the decision concerning their own publication.
In the event of a conflict of interest involving the Editor-in-Chief, responsibility for handling the manuscript in question must be transferred to another member of the Editorial Board who has no related conflicts of interest.
Management of Conflicts of Interest
The Editorial Board of Agape treats disclosures of potential conflicts of interest confidentially, in accordance with the principles of fairness, proportionality, and respect for all participants in the editorial and publishing process.
Depending on the nature of the circumstances identified, the Editorial Board may request additional explanations, appoint independent reviewers, assign the manuscript to another editor, or decide to reject the submission if the impartiality of the publication process cannot be ensured.
If a significant undisclosed conflict of interest is identified after an article has been published, the Editorial Board conducts an appropriate investigation involving the parties concerned. Depending on the outcome, a clarification or correction to the publication may be issued. In cases where the undisclosed conflict has substantially affected the reliability of the findings or the integrity of the peer review process, the retraction of the article may be initiated.
The conflict of interest policy of Agape is founded on the principles of transparency, academic independence, and accountability on the part of all participants in scholarly communication. Its purpose is to prevent undue influence on research findings and editorial decisions, ensure trust in scholarly publications, and foster a culture of integrity in academic discourse.