Publication Ethics

 

The scientific journal Agape adheres to internationally recognized standards of publication ethics, academic integrity, and responsible scholarly communication. The journal's editorial policy is based on the recommendations of the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE) and the Principles of Transparency and Best Practice in Scholarly Publishing, developed by COPE, the Directory of Open Access Journals (DOAJ), the Open Access Scholarly Publishing Association (OASPA), and the World Association of Medical Editors (WAME).

The journal regards publication ethics as a system of mutual obligations among authors, reviewers, editors, and the publisher, aimed at ensuring the reliability of scientific knowledge, the independence of research, respect for intellectual property, and trust in the results of academic work.

Of particular importance to Agape is fostering a culture of reasoned scholarly debate that is open to a diversity of philosophical, theological, and religious studies approaches. Differences in worldview positions, religious affiliation, or methodological orientations may not serve as grounds for biased evaluation of scholarly materials. The determining criteria for publication are scientific novelty, originality, methodological soundness, well-substantiated conclusions, and the relevance of the research to the journal's scope.

 

1. General Principles of Publication Ethics

The editorial activities of Agape are based on the following principles:

  • academic integrity and the inadmissibility of any form of scientific misconduct;

  • independence of editorial decisions from financial, administrative, political, religious, or other external influence;

  • objectivity, impartiality, and transparency in manuscript evaluation and peer review procedures;

  • respect for copyright, intellectual property, and proper acknowledgment of scholarly contributions;

  • confidentiality of information obtained during the editorial processing of manuscripts;

  • prevention of conflicts of interest and provision of appropriate mechanisms for their resolution;

  • responsibility for the timely identification and correction of errors and the consideration of reports of possible violations of publication ethics;

  • support for academic freedom, scholarly pluralism, and constructive critical debate.

Compliance with these principles is mandatory for all participants in the editorial and publishing process.

 

2. Ethical Obligations of the Editorial Board and Editors

The Editorial Board of Agape is responsible for organizing a transparent, independent, and professional review of manuscripts, ensuring the appropriate quality of published materials, and complying with established editorial procedures.

Editorial Decision-Making. Decisions regarding the acceptance or rejection of manuscripts are made on the basis of their relevance to the journal's academic scope, originality, relevance, the strength of the research argument, the reliability of the sources used, and the recommendations of independent reviewers.

The final decision on publication rests with the Editor-in-Chief or an authorized editor, in accordance with the journal's internal procedures. Reviewers' recommendations constitute an important basis for decision-making but do not replace editorial responsibility.

Equality and Impartiality. The Editorial Board ensures equal consideration of scholarly materials regardless of the authors' citizenship, nationality, gender, age, racial or ethnic origin, religious beliefs, worldview or political views, or institutional affiliation.

The journal recognizes researchers' right to formulate and defend their scholarly positions independently and with reasoned arguments. At the same time, academic freedom entails responsibility for the soundness of conclusions, the reliability of the information used, and compliance with professional ethical standards.

Confidentiality. Editors and members of the Editorial Board are required to maintain the confidentiality of information concerning submitted manuscripts. Access to unpublished materials is granted only to individuals directly involved in their evaluation, peer review, and editorial processing.

The use of unpublished findings, ideas, arguments, or manuscript materials in one's own research without the authors' appropriate permission is prohibited.

Conflicts of Interest. Editors who have a personal, professional, financial, or other interest in the outcome of the evaluation of a particular manuscript are required to disclose the relevant circumstances and recuse themselves from making decisions regarding its publication.

Responsibility for Publication Quality. The Editorial Board ensures an appropriate response to substantiated reports of plagiarism, fabrication or falsification of data, copyright infringement, and other cases of unethical research practice.

If errors or significant violations are identified after publication, the Editorial Board takes appropriate measures to preserve the integrity of the scholarly record.

 

3. Ethical Obligations of Authors

Authors submitting manuscripts to Agape are responsible for the originality, reliability, and scholarly soundness of the results presented, compliance with the principles of academic integrity, and adherence to the journal's editorial requirements.

Originality of Research. Submitted materials must contain original research findings, appropriately substantiated conclusions, and correctly formatted references to the sources used. Appropriating another person's ideas, texts, concepts, translations, or research findings without appropriate attribution is unacceptable.

Reliability and Scholarly Argumentation. Authors are required to ensure the accuracy of the facts, quotations, bibliographic information, and interpretations presented. In philosophical, theological, and religious studies research, particular importance is attached to the proper use of primary sources, due consideration of historical and intellectual contexts, and the soundness of the interpretations proposed.

Authors must clearly distinguish their own conclusions from the positions of other researchers, historical evidence, and interpretative assumptions.

Prevention of Duplicate Publication. Manuscripts submitted to Agape must not be under consideration by other scholarly journals simultaneously. Authors are required to inform the Editorial Board of any prior dissemination of research materials, including in the form of preprints, and to appropriately cite their own previous publications when their content is used in a new manuscript.

Authorship and Scholarly Contribution. Only individuals who have made a substantial intellectual contribution to the development of the research concept, the conduct of the research, the analysis of its results, or the preparation of the scholarly text, have approved the final version of the manuscript, and accept responsibility for their respective contributions may be listed as co-authors.

It is unacceptable to include individuals who have not made an appropriate scholarly contribution in the list of co-authors, or to fail to acknowledge the authorship of individuals who have a legitimate claim to it.

The contributions of individuals whose participation does not meet the criteria for authorship may be acknowledged in the acknowledgments section, with their consent.

Research Ethics. Authors must respect the rights, dignity, privacy, and beliefs of individuals and communities participating in or serving as subjects of research. When conducting interviews, field observations, sociological, anthropological, and other empirical studies, authors must comply with the relevant ethical requirements, particularly those concerning informed consent, personal data protection, and confidentiality.

Communication with the Editorial Board. Authors are required to respond promptly to substantiated editorial requests, duly address reviewers' comments, or provide reasoned explanations for disagreeing with them. If significant errors are identified in their own published article, authors must notify the Editorial Board and cooperate in correcting them.

 

4. Ethical Principles of Peer Review

Peer review is an integral component of ensuring the scholarly quality of publications in Agape. Its purpose is to provide an independent expert assessment of research, identify its strengths and weaknesses, and formulate reasoned recommendations regarding its suitability for publication.

Reviewers are required to adhere to the following principles:

  • Competence. Evaluate only manuscripts whose subject matter falls within their academic qualifications and research expertise.

  • Impartiality. Conduct evaluations on the basis of scholarly criteria, without allowing personal preferences, professional rivalry, or differences in worldview to influence their judgment.

  • Reasoned Assessment. Formulate specific, substantiated, and constructive comments aimed at improving the scholarly quality of the manuscript. Personal criticism of the author, discriminatory judgments, and inappropriate language are unacceptable.

  • Confidentiality. Do not disclose the contents of unpublished materials, share them with third parties, or use the information obtained for personal benefit.

  • Academic Integrity. Inform the Editorial Board of any identified indications of plagiarism, improper citation, substantial textual similarities, or possible distortion of research findings.

  • Conflict of Interest Resolution. Promptly inform the Editorial Board of any circumstances that may affect the independence of the expert assessment and decline to review manuscripts in cases where impartiality cannot be ensured.

The journal particularly emphasizes the need to distinguish scholarly criticism from differences in worldview. A reviewer must not require an author to change their philosophical beliefs, theological position, or methodological orientation if the proposed approach meets academic standards, is properly substantiated, and is consistent with the subject of the research.

Reviewers' conclusions are advisory in nature and are taken into account by the Editorial Board when making the final publication decision.

 

5. Ethical Obligations of the Publisher

The publisher of Agape provides the organizational and technical conditions necessary for implementing the journal's editorial policy, properly disseminating scholarly materials, and maintaining their accessibility.

The publisher contributes to:

  • ensuring the independence of the Editorial Board and preventing external influence on publication decisions;

  • respecting copyright and complying with the established licensing terms for scholarly materials;

  • protecting confidential information obtained during the editorial and publishing process;

  • ensuring the proper technical processing, dissemination, and accessibility of scholarly publications;

  • promptly issuing corrections, publishing retraction notices, and implementing other editorial decisions necessary to preserve the integrity of the scholarly record;

  • complying with the principles of open access and free publication in accordance with the journal's editorial policy.

Authors retain copyright to their scholarly works, and their publication is carried out in accordance with Agape's open access policy and the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0) licence.

 

6. Prevention of Violations of Publication Ethics and Procedures for Their Investigation

The Editorial Board of Agape considers all substantiated reports of possible violations of academic integrity, regardless of whether they concern manuscripts under review or materials that have already been published.

Upon receiving a report of a possible violation, the Editorial Board conducts a preliminary assessment of the circumstances, requests explanations from the relevant individuals where necessary, and may involve independent experts.

Such cases are considered in accordance with the principles of confidentiality, impartiality, and fairness. Individuals who have a conflict of interest concerning the subject of the investigation or its participants must not take part in the relevant decision-making process.

Depending on the nature of the violations established, the Editorial Board may decide to reject the manuscript, issue corrections to a published article, publish an editorial notice, or retract the publication.

Retraction is applied in cases where established violations or significant deficiencies call into question the reliability of the research findings or the integrity of the publication process. A retracted article generally remains accessible in the journal's archive, clearly marked as retracted and accompanied by a reference to the relevant editorial notice.

The Editorial Board ensures proper documentation of decisions concerning corrections or retractions and their transparency to the scholarly community.

 

7. Consideration of Complaints and Appeals

Authors have the right to request an explanation of an editorial decision or submit a reasoned appeal if they disagree with the rejection of a manuscript or with findings concerning possible violations of publication ethics.

An appeal must contain a clear justification of the applicant's position and, where necessary, relevant supporting materials.

The Editorial Board considers such appeals impartially, involving individuals who have no conflict of interest. Where necessary, the manuscript may be referred for additional independent peer review.

Complaints concerning the actions of editors, reviewers, or other participants in the publication process are considered by the Editor-in-Chief or, if the complaint concerns the Editor-in-Chief's conduct, by another authorized representative of the Editorial Board.

The applicant is informed of the decision resulting from the consideration of the appeal, together with the main reasons underlying it.

 

8. Responsibility for Compliance with Ethical Standards

Compliance with the principles of publication ethics is a shared responsibility of the authors, reviewers, Editorial Board, and publisher of Agape.

The journal supports openness to substantiated scholarly criticism, the correction of identified errors, and further academic discussion of published findings.

The Editorial Board regards publication ethics not merely as a set of procedural requirements, but also as an expression of a responsible attitude toward scientific inquiry, intellectual honesty, and respect for alternative research positions. These principles define Agape's commitment to serving as a space for ethical academic communication, critical reflection, and constructive dialogue among different traditions of humanistic scholarship.