Peer Review Process

The scientific journal Agape ensures independent, objective, and impartial evaluation of manuscripts in accordance with international standards of publication ethics and academic integrity.

 

All original research articles and review studies submitted to the journal are subject to mandatory independent peer review under the principle of double-anonymous peer review, whereby authors and reviewers are not provided with information about each other's identities.

The purpose of peer review is to ensure the scholarly quality of publications, assess the originality and significance of research findings, methodological soundness, the strength of authors' conclusions, and their contribution to the advancement of philosophical, theological, and religious studies scholarship.

The peer review procedure of Agape is based on the recommendations of the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE) and the principles of transparency and good practice in academic publishing.

1. Submission and Preliminary Editorial Assessment

The author submits the manuscript through the journal's electronic submission system in accordance with the established requirements for the formatting of scholarly materials and the provisions of the editorial policy.

Upon receipt, the manuscript undergoes a preliminary editorial assessment, which includes:

  • determining whether the material is consistent with the journal's academic scope and thematic areas;

  • checking compliance with technical formatting requirements;

  • assessing the presence of the essential structural elements of a scholarly publication;

  • checking the originality of the text and compliance with the principles of academic integrity;

  • conducting a preliminary assessment of scientific novelty, methodological soundness, and the quality of argumentation.

The Editorial Board aims to notify the author of the results of the preliminary assessment within 14 calendar days of receiving the manuscript.

Materials that do not meet the established requirements may be returned to the authors for revision or rejected, with the main reasons for the decision specified.

A positive decision following the preliminary assessment means that the manuscript is eligible for peer review but does not guarantee its subsequent publication.

2. Appointment of Reviewers

Manuscripts approved for expert evaluation are submitted to at least two independent reviewers with appropriate academic qualifications and research experience in the field to which the submitted material belongs.

Reviewers may include members of the journal's Editorial Board, as well as invited Ukrainian and international scholars who have no conflict of interest concerning the particular manuscript.

Reviewers are selected by the Editor-in-Chief or a member of the Editorial Board authorized by the Editor-in-Chief, taking into account the subject specialization, methodological orientation of the research, and the need to ensure independent expert evaluation.

In the case of interdisciplinary research, specialists from different academic fields may be invited to participate in the review process.

Before accepting a manuscript for review, an invited expert must confirm their competence in the relevant subject area, their ability to complete the evaluation within the agreed timeframe, and the absence of circumstances that could compromise their impartiality.

If a conflict of interest is identified, the reviewer is required to notify the Editorial Board and decline to evaluate the manuscript.

3. Ensuring Anonymity and Confidentiality

Peer review at Agape is conducted according to the principle of double anonymity: reviewers are not informed of the authors' identities, and authors are not informed of the reviewers' identities.

To ensure anonymity, authors must submit a version of the manuscript without personal data, information about institutional affiliations, or other details that could directly reveal their identity. Author information is submitted separately through the journal's electronic system.

Self-citation is permitted provided that it is academically justified and formatted in such a way that it does not disclose authorship during the review process.

All materials received by reviewers for evaluation are considered confidential. Reviewers are not permitted to share manuscripts with third parties, use unpublished materials in their own research, or disclose their contents without proper authorization.

Communication between authors and reviewers takes place exclusively through the Editorial Board via the journal's electronic system.

4. Criteria for Expert Evaluation

Reviewers conduct a scholarly analysis of the manuscript based on the following main criteria:

  1. Relevance to the journal's scope: whether the research falls within the fields of philosophy, theology, religious studies, or related interdisciplinary areas.

  2. Relevance and scholarly significance: the soundness of the formulation of the research problem and its theoretical or practical importance.

  3. Originality and scientific novelty: the presence of an independent authorial contribution, new approaches, arguments, findings, or interpretations.

  4. Methodological soundness: the appropriateness of the selected methods in relation to the research aim and objectives, and consistency in their application.

  5. Engagement with scholarly literature: adequate consideration of previous research, the current state of scholarly debate, and relevant academic sources.

  6. Accuracy in the use of primary sources: reliability of citations, accuracy of translations, and proper consideration of historical, cultural, philosophical, or theological contexts.

  7. Strength of argumentation and logical consistency: coherence of the main propositions, substantiation of conclusions, and their correspondence to the stated research objectives.

  8. Academic integrity: compliance with requirements concerning originality, proper citation, copyright, and the reliability of the findings presented.

  9. Quality of academic writing: clarity of structure, accuracy of terminology, and clarity and consistency in the presentation of scholarly arguments.

    10. Scholarly contribution: the research's potential to advance the relevant field of knowledge and contribute to further academic discussion.

The peer review of philosophical, theological, and religious studies research requires respect for the diversity of methodological approaches and intellectual traditions. A reviewer's differences in worldview, religious affiliation, or theoretical orientation from the author's position cannot, in themselves, constitute grounds for a negative assessment, provided that the research meets academic standards and the proposed position is adequately substantiated.

5. Preparation of the Review

Following the evaluation, the reviewer completes a standardized review form approved by the Editorial Board of Agape.

The review must contain a reasoned analysis of the manuscript's scholarly quality, comments and recommendations for possible improvements to the research, and a final assessment.

The reviewer may recommend:

  • acceptance of the article for publication;

  • acceptance of the article subject to minor revisions;

  • return of the article to the author for major revisions, followed by a second round of peer review;

  • rejection of the article on the grounds that it does not meet the journal's requirements or the required level of scholarly quality.

Recommendations must be clear, substantiated, and constructive. Personal criticism of authors, discriminatory statements, and unsubstantiated evaluative judgments are unacceptable.

The duration of the peer review process is determined by taking into account the complexity and length of the research, as well as the availability of the experts involved. In cases of significant delays, the Editorial Board informs the author about the status of the manuscript review.

6. Manuscript Revision and Subsequent Peer Review

If the expert evaluation indicates that the manuscript requires revision, the Editorial Board sends the author the relevant comments and recommendations without disclosing the reviewers' identities.

The author must prepare a revised version of the article and provide a separate document containing responses to the reviewers' comments, indicating the changes made or providing reasoned explanations for disagreeing with particular recommendations.

The author has the right to defend their research position with reasoned arguments if the reviewer's comments concern debatable interpretations, methodological approaches, or theoretical propositions on which there is no established consensus in the relevant academic field.

The need for a second round of peer review is determined by the Editorial Board, taking into account the nature of the revisions made and the previous expert assessments.

In cases of substantial revision, the revised manuscript is generally resubmitted to the reviewers for evaluation.

7. Disagreements Between Reviewers and Additional Evaluation

In cases of significant discrepancies between reviewers' assessments, the Editorial Board conducts an additional analysis of their arguments.

If necessary, the Editor-in-Chief may appoint a third independent reviewer or refer the manuscript to the relevant members of the Editorial Board for consideration.

A positive review does not automatically guarantee acceptance of a manuscript, just as an individual negative assessment does not necessarily result in its unconditional rejection.

The editorial decision is made on the basis of the overall assessment of the expert opinions, the nature of the identified shortcomings, the strength of the author's explanations, and the manuscript's compliance with the academic standards of Agape.

8. Final Decision-Making

The final decision regarding the publication of a manuscript is made by the Editor-in-Chief or an authorized editor, or, where necessary, by the journal's Editorial Board.

The decision is based on the results of independent peer review, the evaluation of the revised manuscript, compliance with the editorial policy, and adherence to the principles of academic integrity.

The author is notified of the decision through the journal's electronic system.

The date on which an article is accepted for publication is considered to be the date of the final positive editorial decision, following the completion of all necessary stages of peer review and manuscript revision.

Once accepted, the article is included in the journal's editorial portfolio and prepared for publication in accordance with the publishing schedule.

9. Editorial Processing of Accepted Articles

Following final acceptance, the manuscript is forwarded for language, stylistic, and technical editing.

The Editorial Board reserves the right to make necessary proofreading and technical corrections that do not alter the scholarly content, main arguments, or the author's line of reasoning.

Any changes that may affect the content of the research, the interpretation of findings, or the formulation of conclusions must be approved by the author.

Before publication, the author is given the opportunity to review the final editorial version of the article and report any errors identified.

The authors of the publication bear responsibility for the scholarly soundness, reliability of the findings, and content of the author's conclusions.

10. Appeals Against Peer Review Outcomes

The author has the right to submit a reasoned appeal in cases of disagreement with an editorial decision or where there are substantiated doubts concerning the objectivity of the expert evaluation.

An appeal must be submitted to the journal's Editorial Board in writing, specifying the particular grounds for reconsideration of the decision.

The Editor-in-Chief or another authorized member of the Editorial Board considers the appeal and determines whether additional evaluation of the manuscript is necessary.

If procedural violations, substantiated indications of bias, or significant shortcomings in the peer review process are identified, the Editorial Board may appoint a new independent expert evaluation.

Appeals are considered in accordance with the principles of impartiality, confidentiality, and fairness.

11. Specifics of Evaluating Other Types of Publications

Scholarly reviews of monographs, reviews of academic publications, materials from scholarly discussions, and other texts that do not fall into the category of original research articles may undergo editorial evaluation, taking into account their nature and publishing purpose.

Where necessary, such materials may be submitted for independent expert peer review.

The Editorial Board ensures transparency in evaluation procedures and indicates the specific editorial review arrangements applied to materials that have not undergone the standard double-anonymous peer review process.

12. General Provisions

All participants in the peer review process are required to comply with the editorial policies of Agape, including the provisions on publication ethics, conflicts of interest, anti-plagiarism, confidentiality, and the use of artificial intelligence.

Peer review and all stages of the editorial assessment of manuscripts are provided free of charge to authors.

The Editorial Board of Agape regards independent expert peer review not merely as an instrument for quality control in scholarly publishing, but also as an important form of responsible academic dialogue that contributes to the development of research culture, the strengthening of argumentation, and the creation of a space for open and ethical scholarly communication.