Complaints and Appeals
The scientific journal Agape adheres to the principles of openness, fairness, impartiality, and accountability in handling complaints and appeals related to editorial decisions, the peer-review process, compliance with academic integrity, and publication ethics.
The policy for handling submissions is based on the recommendations of the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE) and international standards of responsible scholarly publishing.
The Editorial Board recognises the right of authors, reviewers, readers, and other interested parties to submit substantiated complaints concerning possible violations of editorial procedures, professional ethics, or academic integrity.
Complaints and appeals must be submitted to the journal's official email address: agape@chnu.edu.ua
1. General Principles for Handling Submissions
The Editorial Board of Agape ensures that complaints and appeals are handled in accordance with the following principles:
- Impartiality and independence: individuals directly involved in the circumstances that are the subject of a complaint, or those who have a conflict of interest, shall not participate in the relevant decision-making process.
- Fairness: all interested parties are given the opportunity to present their position, provide explanations, and submit relevant supporting materials.
- Confidentiality: information obtained during the handling of submissions is used solely for the purpose of properly establishing the circumstances and is not disclosed without justified necessity.
- Reasoned decision-making: decisions resulting from the consideration of a complaint or appeal must be based on verified circumstances, the provisions of the Editorial Policy, and the principles of publication ethics.
- Timeliness: the Editorial Board endeavours to handle submissions without undue delay, taking into account the complexity of the matter and the need to involve additional experts.
- Mutual respect: all participants in the procedure are required to observe the standards of professional academic communication.
The good-faith submission of a complaint or appeal shall not constitute grounds for discrimination against the complainant or for prejudicial treatment of their subsequent scholarly publications.
2. Procedure for Submitting Complaints and Appeals
Complaints and appeals must be submitted in writing to the editorial office of the journal Agape by email.
A submission must contain:
1. The complainant's first and last name and contact details (except in cases of justified anonymous reports of violations).
2. The title of the manuscript or published article and its identifying details, if the submission concerns a specific work.
3. A clear description of the circumstances that prompted the complaint or appeal.
4. The grounds supporting the claims, with references to relevant facts, documents, editorial decisions, or provisions of publication ethics.
5. The expected means of resolving the matter raised.
The Editorial Board may also consider anonymous reports of suspected breaches of academic integrity, provided they contain sufficiently specific information to allow an objective investigation.
3. Procedure for Handling Submissions
Upon receipt of a complaint or appeal, the Editorial Board conducts a preliminary review, establishes the subject matter of the submission, and determines the procedure for further investigation of the circumstances.
Main stages of the review:
1. Registration of the submission. The Editorial Board acknowledges its receipt and, where necessary, contacts the complainant to clarify the information or request additional materials.
2. Preliminary assessment. The Editor-in-Chief assesses the nature of the complaint or appeal, its substantiation, and whether it falls within the competence of the journal's Editorial Board.
3. Appointment of those responsible for the review. Where necessary, the Editor-in-Chief involves at least two members of the Editorial Board who possess relevant scholarly expertise and editorial experience and have no conflict of interest concerning the subject matter of the submission.
4. Establishing the circumstances. The Editorial Board examines the submitted documents, editorial correspondence, reviewers' reports, and other relevant materials. Where necessary, it obtains explanations from interested parties or engages independent experts.
5. Decision-making. Following the review, the substantiation of the submission is assessed and the measures necessary to resolve the situation are determined.
6. Notification of the complainant. The Editorial Board sends a written response outlining the decision made and its principal grounds, to the extent permitted by confidentiality requirements.
If a complaint concerns the actions or decisions of the Editor-in-Chief, the latter shall not participate in its consideration. The relevant submission is referred to another authorised representative of the Editorial Board, who organises an independent review involving individuals with no conflict of interest.
4. Appeals Against Editorial Decisions
Authors have the right to appeal a decision to reject a manuscript or any other editorial decision if they believe it was made in violation of established procedures, on the basis of a significant factual misunderstanding, or as a result of biased expert assessment.
An appeal must contain specific arguments explaining the reasons for disagreement with the Editorial Board's decision. When appealing reviewers' conclusions, the author must provide a point-by-point response to the relevant comments, indicating the factual or methodological grounds for reconsidering the decision.
An author's mere disagreement with a negative assessment of a manuscript, without proper substantiation, does not constitute sufficient grounds for upholding an appeal.
Where necessary, the Editorial Board may arrange additional independent peer review, involve another editor in the assessment of the manuscript, or refer the matter for consideration by the Editorial Board.
Following consideration of an appeal, the Editorial Board may adopt one of the following decisions:
- to uphold the original editorial decision;
- to reconsider the original decision and resume the manuscript review process;
- to refer the manuscript for additional independent peer review;
- to invite the author to resubmit a revised version of the manuscript.
Upholding an appeal does not automatically entail acceptance of the article for publication; rather, it involves reinstating the proper procedure for its scholarly evaluation.
The decision made following the internal appeals review is final within the scope of this procedure. Reconsideration is possible if significant new circumstances emerge or new evidence of breaches of publication ethics is presented.
5. Complaints Concerning Breaches of Publication Ethics
The Editorial Board of Agape considers reports of possible breaches of academic integrity and professional ethics by authors, reviewers, editors, and other participants in the publication process.
Grounds for submitting a complaint may include, in particular:
- suspicions of academic plagiarism, fabrication, or falsification of research findings;
- violations of authorship rules, intellectual property rights, or proper citation practices;
- concealment of a significant conflict of interest;
- breaches of the confidentiality of peer review and editorial correspondence;
- manifestations of bias, discrimination, or inappropriate professional conduct;
- non-compliance with editorial policies, including those governing the use of generative artificial intelligence;
- the identification of significant errors or unreliable information in already published materials.
Such submissions are handled in accordance with COPE principles and the internal policies of the journal Agape.
The Editorial Board ensures that reported circumstances are properly investigated and that no premature conclusions are drawn regarding the culpability of any party.
If a complaint concerns an already published article, the Editorial Board may, following the investigation, decide that no further action is warranted, issue corrections, publish an editorial notice, or retract the publication if the established circumstances meet the grounds for applying such a measure.
In complex cases, the Editorial Board may seek clarification from relevant academic institutions or independent experts, in compliance with confidentiality requirements and applicable legislation.
6. Timeframes for Handling Submissions and Notifying Complainants
The Editorial Board of Agape endeavours to ensure the timely handling of complaints and appeals and to avoid undue delays in the procedure.
The duration of the review depends on the nature of the submission, the scope of the investigation required, the number of parties involved, and the need for additional expert assessment.
If the review requires an extended period of time, the Editorial Board informs the complainant of the progress made in handling the submission and the estimated timeframe for completing the procedure.
All decisions are documented and retained in the editorial archive in compliance with confidentiality requirements and personal data protection regulations.
7. Final Provisions
The Complaints and Appeals Policy is an integral part of the overall system for ensuring academic integrity, transparency, and accountability in the editorial activities of Agape.
The Editorial Board recognises the right to reasoned disagreement, academic criticism, and fair reconsideration of decisions, while ensuring the independence of scholarly peer review and compliance with high standards of publication ethics.
Contact address for submitting complaints and appeals: agape@chnu.edu.ua