Artificial Intelligence Policy
The journal’s editorial policy is based on the recommendations of the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE) and takes into account Elsevier’s policy on the use of generative AI in scholarly journals.
The fundamental principle of the journal is to preserve human responsibility for the scholarly content, originality, reliability and integrity of research. Artificial intelligence tools may serve supporting functions, but must not replace independent scholarly thinking, critical analysis or the author’s intellectual contribution.
Authorship and Responsibility
Generative artificial intelligence tools, including ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini and other similar systems, cannot be listed as authors or co-authors of scholarly publications, as they are unable to take responsibility for research findings, confirm the originality of research, declare conflicts of interest or ensure compliance with copyright requirements.
Authors bear full responsibility for the content of submitted manuscripts, including information obtained or processed with the assistance of AI tools. They are required to verify the reliability of facts, the accuracy of references, the authenticity of quotations, the accuracy of translations and the validity of scholarly conclusions, regardless of how the relevant materials were prepared.
The use of AI does not exempt authors from complying with the requirements of academic integrity, copyright law or the proper citation of sources used.
Permissible Uses of AI
The journal permits the use of generative AI tools as an auxiliary means in the research and manuscript preparation process, in particular for:
-
language and stylistic editing of scholarly texts;
-
translation of individual passages, abstracts and other parts of a manuscript, subject to mandatory verification of translation accuracy;
-
preliminary searching, systematisation and thematic grouping of scholarly literature;
-
structuring research materials and improving the coherence of their presentation;
-
supporting information analysis, data processing and other research tasks, provided that these are methodologically justified.
Given the specific nature of philosophical, theological and religious studies research, particular attention is paid to the reliability of interpretations of primary sources, the accurate rendering of philosophical and theological terminology, and the authenticity of biblical, patristic, historical-philosophical and other texts.
The use of AI-generated fabricated quotations, bibliographic references, historical facts or research findings as reliable scholarly information is strictly prohibited. Nor may AI-generated content reproduced uncritically be used as a substitute for the author’s own argumentation, independent analysis or scholarly conclusions.
All sources suggested or processed with the assistance of AI must be verified by authors against the original publications.
Declaration of Generative AI Use
Authors are required to inform the Editorial Board of any use of generative AI that has influenced the preparation of the manuscript’s content, the structuring of its argumentation, translation, source analysis, data processing or other substantial aspects of the research.
The use of tools solely for basic spelling, grammar and punctuation checks does not require a separate declaration.
Information on the use of generative AI must be provided when submitting the manuscript in the “Comments for the Editor” field and in a dedicated section of the article entitled “Declaration of Artificial Intelligence Use”, placed before the list of references.
The declaration must include:
-
The first and last name(s) of the author(s) who used AI tools.
-
The name of the tool used, its developer, and its version or model (if this information is available).
-
The specific tasks for which AI was used and the nature of its involvement in the research or manuscript preparation.
-
Confirmation that the author(s) exercised oversight, verified the results obtained and accept full responsibility for the final content of the publication.
Example of a declaration:
“The author(s), [first and last name(s)], declare(s) the use of the generative artificial intelligence tool [name, developer, model/version] during the preparation of the manuscript for [specify the tasks: language editing, translation, source systematisation, supporting data analysis, etc.]. All results obtained were critically reviewed, processed and, where necessary, revised by the author(s). The author(s) confirm(s) full responsibility for the reliability, originality and scholarly validity of the final text of the publication.”
If AI tools were used directly as part of the research methodology, this information must also be included in the description of the research methods, with sufficient detail to enable the scholarly validity of the results to be assessed.
Use of AI in the Editorial Process and Peer Review
Editors, members of the Editorial Board and reviewers of the journal Agape are required to ensure the confidentiality of submitted manuscripts and uphold the principles of independent expert assessment.
Uploading unpublished manuscripts, excerpts from them, peer-review materials or other confidential information to publicly accessible generative AI systems is prohibited unless adequate data protection is ensured and the necessary consent of the authors has been obtained.
AI tools must not be used to generate final peer-review reports automatically, independently determine the scholarly quality of research or make editorial decisions.
The auxiliary use of secure AI tools for language editing or technical processing of materials is permitted, provided that confidentiality is maintained, such use is appropriately declared, and the responsible editor or reviewer retains full oversight.
Final decisions concerning the scholarly quality of a manuscript, its acceptance, revision or rejection are made exclusively by authorised participants in the editorial process.
Policy Violations and Accountability
Failure to disclose substantial use of generative AI, submission of unverified or fabricated information produced with its assistance, copyright infringement or violations of other principles of academic integrity constitute grounds for additional editorial scrutiny.
If potential violations are identified, the Editorial Board may request explanations from the authors, ask them to provide additional materials or initiate an independent expert assessment.
Confirmed substantial violations of this policy may constitute grounds for rejecting a manuscript. If a violation is identified after publication, the Editorial Board may decide to publish a correction or retract the article, depending on the nature and consequences of the violation.
The Editorial Board of Agape supports the development of technological innovation in scholarly activity while consistently upholding the primacy of human intellectual responsibility, critical thinking and academic integrity as indispensable foundations of scholarly inquiry.